Notes: In case you aren't familiar with Mildred, Mordred and Cynthia, the hostesses of the Witching Hour, here's an intro, leading into the chilling tales they'll tell! (2 pages in the beginning and 1 page closing the issue were reprinted from Witching Hour #2(April-May, 1969))
Notes: If you could bring one thing from the future, what would you want? Thurgood Trapley thought he knew - but he had a surprise coming! 5 page story introduced by Mildred originally appeared in Witching Hour #1 (February-March, 1969).
Notes: Stanley wanted one thing out of life ... to ride the perfect wave. Then he heard where he could find it - at a very unusual beach! 5 page story originally published in Witching Hour #1 (February-March, 1969) introduced by Cynthia.
Notes: A blind man cheats to get a new pair of eyes ... eyes that give him the power to see into the future! 6 page story introduced by Mildred was reprinted from House of Mystery #47 (February, 1956).
Notes: Some men look for an ideal - a perfect woman! They'll be satisfied with nothing less! This is the story of a man who found her - but had to fight dragons for her! 6 page story was originally published in House of Mystery #69 (December, 1957) and is introduced by Cynthia.
Notes: The condemned man told Johnny Peril he'd change places with him so that Johnny would be hanged in his place! And Johnny laughed - until the hands reached out of the mirror! 8 page reprint story from Sensation Comics #109 (May-June, 1952) introduced by Mildred.
Notes: He was rescued from the sea by a ship - but when he found what the vessel was like, he decided he'd rather return to the sea! 4 page reprint story from House of Mystery #68 (November, 1957)introduced by Mordred.
Notes: It was an amusing story in the old manuscript - of a 20th century man who traveled to the past. But it was only a story - wasn't it? 6 page story reprinted from House of Secrets #8 (January-February, 1958) introduced by Cynthia.
Notes: This issue's lucky 13th story ... of a coin that brought good luck only to those who gave it away! 4 page story introduced by all 3 witches was reprinted from Phantom Stranger #4 (February-March, 1953).