May Contest!  |  Add New Content  |  Top Issues  |  Register  |  Marketplace  |  Forums  |  Request a Feature  |  Help  |  Mobile  |  Home


Register for free
Social Media: Facebook Twitter Tumblr

  Search by Cover Date

  Story Arcs
  Public Collections
  Public User Lists

Last 10 titles added:
  1. Batman: The Golden Age O...
  2. The Golden Age of Batman...
  3. The Greatest American Co...
  4. The Unauthorized Lampoon...
  5. Political Power: Rush Li...
  6. G.I. Joe Cobra World War...
  7. Ghostbusters Annual (201...
  8. Justice League The Darks...
  9. Justice League The Darks...
  10. The Mighty Thor (2016)
   View All

Last 10 creators added:
  1. Kathy Palin
  2. Rocky Walters
  3. J.B. Fernandes
  4. Andrew Hoffmann
  5. Christian Patchell
  6. Neil Paniry
  7. M. T. Quach
  8. Ian Ally-Seals
  9. Peter Hannan
  10. Nick Cross
   View All

Last 10 characters added:
  1. Reuse
  2. Loup Noir
  3. Couik
  4. Manitou (Marvel)(02 - de...
  5. Chairman (Top Cow)(Rebir...
  6. Chairwoman (Top Cow)(Reb...
  7. Ballistic (Top Cow)(Rebi...
  8. Reyna, Martin
  9. Hassan, Nadeen
  10. Kraye (Marvel), Paul
   View All

What If...? (1989) - #51
"What If the Punisher had Become Captain America?"

Change this cover
or add a variant
Simon Furman

Paris Cullins

Dave Cooper
Frank Turner

Carlos Lopez

Janice Chiang

Tom DeFalco
Rob Tokar

Cover Artist(s):
Art Nichols

Rating (out of 10):
from 6 votes

You must be logged in to vote!

Other members' collections
  This issue is in 170 collections.

  This issue is available for sale/trade

Edit this Issue
Clone this Issue
View this issue's contribution history
Clone the creators of this issue
Clone the characters of this issue
Suggest a podcast for this issue


Search for 'What If...?' on Amazon

Cover Date: July 1993
Cover Price: US $ 1.25

Issue Tagline: None.

Format: Color; Standard Comic Issue; 47 pages

There are other versions of this issue in the database:
What If...? (1989) #51 Newsstand Edition

Story Arc(s):    Add/remove story arcs to this issue

Frank Castle reluctantly agrees to take over as Captain America after Steve Rogers is severely injured. He soon begins moonlighting as Punisher.


Characters:    Add/remove characters to this issue
An image for Punisher (Marvel) exists Punisher (Marvel)

Groups:    Add/remove groups to this issue

Reviews: There is 1 review for this issue - Add your review

Multiple Stories in this Issue

Add a story to this issue

Multiple stories do not exist for this issue.


© 2005-2015 - Terms and Conditions - Privacy Policy Special thanks to Brian Wood for the logo design