13 years after the Chaos! event and the disappearance of many of the world's heroes, Brother Voodoo dreams of his brother Daniel's death. To find answers, he seeks the aid of Dr. Strange, only to find the Eye of Agamotto (presumably) calling upon him to gather the other "Supernaturals" (Satana, Ghost Rider, the Black Cat, Werewolf-by-Night, and the Gargoyle). These events are being watched by Jack O'Lantern, scheming with evil intentions.