Matt doesn't seem to be too welcome in Redemption. After a long night of spying on Gideon beating his wife, Matt's life is made even harder when Gideon attempts to turn the town against him. Later that day, Constance uncovers some bite marks on the body, which she faxed to Foggy for an expert opinion. The forensic orthodonist agrees to appear as an expert witness and they work on getting teeth casts made of the three accused and of Gideon. But Gideon is tipped off to their plan and he breaks all of the teeth out of his mouth to foil Matt.